Legends of Organ Theft: The Moral Dilemma of Contemporary Society

  • Dragana Antonijević Department of Ethnology and Anthropology Faculty of Philosophy University of Belgrade
Keywords:
urban legend, kidney theft, moral dilemma, organ donation, semantic analysis, legend transformation scheme

Abstract

Legends and rumors of organ theft became a global phenomenon in the beginning of the 80s, with the information originating from the "Third world" countries. Victims where poor and powerless, typically children. The rumor engaged a series of actions from anthropologists, NGO’s and media trying to ascertain their validity. Before long, the world was divided into two camps: on the one hand where those who believed the rumors, condemning the West for its exploitation of the underdeveloped and the poor that lead to organ theft from healthy individuals, to satisfy the needs of the rich white patients; and the other faction that, through the data, tried to negate these assertions as unfounded and illogical. At the beginning of the 90s, similar reports surfaced in the highly developed societies of Europe and the USA. Unlike the rumors, these where developed, structured narratives with specific content – legends of kidney theft, whose victims were left alive. Internet has brought about the expansion of such stories. None the less, they remained the under-analyzed, not attracting the attention of the politically minded and militant anthropologists who, in the Third world rumors, recognized material for their anti-colonial and mediatory theories. Few have tried to explain the legend and folklore origins of the First world narratives and to ascertain their function without insightful analysis. That is why I engaged in a semantic analysis of the legend in the context of the highly developed societies, with the intent of exposing their message of a deep moral dilemma concerning organ donation. I found that their hidden meaning is "revolutionary", not an inversion that I thought previously, but in accordance with the public discourse that encourages voluntary and legal donations, from cadaver as from living donors, wich is real disadaptive problem for those soceties. I proposed such a meaning by analysing the most unusual and astonishing element in the story. On the other side, the legend- rumors of Third and Second World, in my view, sent an opposite message, showing the reverse side of the transplantation issue, medical progress and a deeper, existential dilemma of life and death, sickness and health, exposing the doubts intertwined with organ transplantation. Interestingly the legends of organ theft that appeared in Serbia during 2007 had more in common with the legends of the Third world, than with the narratives of the developed societies. In the essay, the interposition of the legends from Serbia, that were instigated by the transitional nature of its socioeconomic reality, are elaborated. That has inspired me to put forward a scheme of narrative, geographical and social transformation of the organ theft legends, thus showing their development intertwined with motifs and spatial markers disperses a system of performances around the world.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Antonijević, Dragana. 2007. Merkantilne legende postindustrijskog društva, u Antropologija savremenosti, ur. Saša Nedeljković. Beograd:Srpski genealoški centar – Etnološka biblioteka, knj. 23: 76-91.
Campion-Vincent, Véronique. 1990. The Baby-Parts Story: A New Latin
American Legend, Western Folklore, Contemporary Legends in Emergence, Vol. 49, No.1: 9-25.
Campion-Vincent, Véronique. 1993. Demonologies in Contemporary Legends and Panics. Satanism and Babyparts Stories, Fabula 34: 238-251.
Campion-Vincent, Véronique. 1997. Organ Theft Narratives, Western Folklore, Vol. 56, No. 1: 1-37.
Campion-Vincent, Véronique. 2001. On Organ Theft Narratives, Nancy Scheper-Hughes, Reply, Discussion and Criticism, Current Anthropology, Vol. 42, No. 4: 555-557.
Campion-Vincent, Véronique. 2002. Organ Theft Narratives as Medical and Social Critique, Journal of Folklore Research,Vol. 39, No. 1: 33-50.
Crane, Beverly. 1977. The Structure of Value in "The Roommate's Death": A Methodology for Interpretive Analysis of Folk Legends, Journal of Folklore Institute, Vol. 1:133-149.
Čajkanović, Veselin. 1973. Mit i religija u Srba. Beograd: SKZ.
Daglas, Meri. 1993. Čisto i opasno. XX vek. Beograd.
Donovan, Pamela. 2002. Crime legends in a new medium: Fact, fiction and loss of authority, Theoretical Criminology, Vol. 6, No. 2: 189-215.
Fabijeti, U., R. Maligeti, V. Matera. 2002. Uvod u antropologiju. Od lokalnog do globalnog. Beograd: Clio.
Fine, Gary Alan. 1992. Manufacturing Tales, University of Tennessee Press.
Kovačević, Ivan. 2001. Semiologija mita i rituala I. Tradicija. Beograd: Srpski genealoški centar, Etnološka biblioteka, knj. 3.
Leventhal, Todd. 1994. The Child Organ Trafficking Rumor: A Modern "Urban Legend". A report submitted to the United Nations special rapporteur on the sale of children, child prostitution, and child pornography by the United States Information Agency (USIA), Decembar, 1-35, http://web.archive.org.
Mikkelson, Barbara and David, Urban Legends Reference Pages, www.snopes.com/horrors/robbery/kidney.asp.
Mullen, Patrick. Modern Legend and Rumor Theory, Journal of Folklore Institute, Vol. 9, No. 2/3: 95-109.
Prop, Vladimir. 1982. Morfologija bajki. Beograd: XX vek.
Radford, Benjamin. 1999. Bitter harvest: the organ-snatching urban legends, Sceptical Inquirer, May-June.
Scheper-Hughes, Nancy. 1996. Theft of Life: The Globalization of Organ Stealing Rumours, Anthropology Today,Vol. 12, No. 3: 3-11.
Scheper-Hughes, Nancy. 1998. Truth and rumor on the organ trail, Natural History 107, No. 8: 48 (10).
Scheper-Hughes, Nancy. 2000. The Global Traffic in Human Organs, Current Anthropology, Vol. 41, No. 1: 191-224.
Simmons, Roberta G., Simmons Richard L. 1971. Organ-Transplantation: A Societal Problem. Social Problem, Vol. 19, No. 1: 36-57.
Whatley, M. 2001. Did You Hear about the Girl Who... ? : Contemporary Legends, Folklore & Human Sexuality. New York University Press.
Wilson, Michael. 1998. Legend and Life: "The Boyfriend's Death" and "The Mad Axeman", Folklore 109: 89-95.
Published
2007-09-03
How to Cite
Antonijević, Dragana. 2007. “Legends of Organ Theft: The Moral Dilemma of Contemporary Society”. Issues in Ethnology and Anthropology 2 (2), 35-69. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.21301/eap.v2i2.3.

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 3 > >>